ATTORNEY CASE BRIEFING SUMMARY
PREPARED FOR EXPEDITED INTAKE: NACA CONSUMER COUNSEL
PLAINTIFF / CLIENT: Joseph R. Fears
DEFENDANTS: USAA Federal Savings Bank (Assignee) | General Motors / AutoNation (Originating Dealer)
ASSET INVOLVED: 2025 Chevrolet Traverse (VIN: 1GNEVGRS1SJ123332)
ACTION REQUIRED: Emergency TRO (Federal Court) to Halt Spoliation/Auction & Initiate Affirmative Litigation.
1. FTC Holder in Due Course Rule (16 C.F.R. § 433)
- The vehicle was out of service for 34 cumulative days (Lemon Law/Breach of Warranty).
- Client invoked the FTC Holder Rule against USAA to withhold payment.
- Status: USAA formally responded in writing, explicitly misrepresenting the Holder Rule by claiming they are "separate" from the collateral dispute and directing the client to the dealer.
2. Retaliatory Repossession & Tortious Conversion
- July 22, 2026: Formal Congressional Inquiry initiated by Senator Angela Alsobrooks’ office regarding the Holder Rule dispute.
- July 24, 2026: Exactly 48 hours later, USAA dispatched Platinum Towing to seize the vehicle (Harford County Sheriff Incident #202600168263).
- Status: USAA executed an illegal recovery of a federally disputed asset, triggering UCC Article 9 statutory penalties.
3. UDAAP & OCC Consent Order Violations
- USAA is operating under an active OCC Consent Order (AA-ENF-2024-96) for failing to manage IT risk and compliance.
- Five days after the physical repossession (July 29), USAA’s automated systems generated an auto-pay reauthorization letter for the seized asset, proving total breakdown of internal compliance and servicing structures.
4. FCRA Willful Reporting Violations
- USAA submitted derogatory credit marks to Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion while the debt was subject to a formal, written statutory dispute.
- AUGUST 8, 2026 (AUCTION DATE): USAA has scheduled the collateral for private auction.
- Spoliation of ESI: The vehicle contains critical onboard computer logs, GPS/telemetry data, and key-fob access records from the July 24 seizure. A formal ESI Preservation Hold was served on USAA. If USAA sells the vehicle on August 8, they commit Spoliation of Evidence.
- Objective: Immediate filing of a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) to halt the August 8 auction, prevent spoliation, and demand immediate return of the asset under the Doctrine of Failure of Consideration.
The client has already compiled an impenetrable, fully-documented administrative record. The following evidence is digitized, secured, and ready for immediate transition to federal court exhibits:
- The Promissory Note (NDSA): Contains the FTC Holder Rule clause.
- Formal CFPB Dismissals: USAA’s documented refusal to honor the Holder Rule.
- The 48-Hour Timeline: Proof of Congressional inquiry followed by immediate repossession.
- Audio Evidence: Raw recording of USAA’s escalated customer service representative admitting the communication was a debt collection attempt before abruptly hanging up.
- The Comprehensive Exposure Matrix: A completed mathematical ledger establishing a $160,000+ statutory floor (UCC § 9-625(c)(2), FCRA § 1681n, MD Lemon Law, and Pulliam v. HNL Automotive fee-shifting).
|
JOSEPH R. FEARS Plaintiff, Pro Se outreach@noobogroup.org v. USAA FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK Defendant 10750 McDermott Freeway San Antonio, TX 78288 |
Case No.: ____________________ |
inyourlegalright.com/HarfordCountyClerk
- Document 1: Request for Waiver of Prepaid Costs (Md. Rule 1-325 / Form CC-DC-089)
- Document 2: Verified Complaint for Injunctive Relief, Wrongful Conversion, UCC Article 9 Violations, and Statutory Damages
- Document 3: Emergency Motion for Ex Parte Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction (Md. Rule 15-504)
- Document 4: Motion to Waive Injunction Bond Pursuant to Md. Rule 15-503(c)
- Document 5: Affidavit of Plaintiff Joseph R. Fears in Support of Emergency Relief and Indigence
- Document 6: Proposed Judicial Orders (Fee Waiver, Bond Waiver, Ex Parte TRO)
- Document 7: Emergency Motion for Expedited Discovery and Preservation of Electronically Stored Information (ESI)
- Exhibit A: CFPB Complaint and USAA Response (5 pages)
- Exhibit B: USAA Note, Disclosure, and Security Agreement (NDSA) (8 pages)
- Exhibit C: Law Enforcement Brief (1 page)
- Exhibit D: Harford County Sheriff's Impound Information Sheet (1 page)
- Exhibit E: USPS Certified Mail Return Receipt (May 13, 2026) (1 page)
- Exhibit F: Supplemental Evidentiary Image (1 page)
- Exhibit G: Supplemental Evidentiary Document (1 page)
- Exhibit H: USAA Automated Notice / Correspondence (6 pages)
- Exhibit I: Texas Attorney General Formal Complaint (TCP-048945) (4 pages)
- Exhibit J: Texas Attorney General Notice of USAA Non-Response (2 pages)
- Exhibit K: Texas Attorney General Follow-Up Notice (2 pages)
- Exhibit L: Texas AG Public Information Request Certification (Lauren Downey) (1 page)
- Exhibit M: OnStar Diagnostic Report (U1962 Transmission & Telemetry Failures) (3 pages)
- Exhibit N: General Motors Special Coverage Defect Notice (Radiator Hose Leak) (2 pages)
- Exhibit O: CFPB Complaint #260422-31692951 (Statutory Breach of Warranty & FTC Holder Rule Invocation) (5 pages)
- Exhibit P: CFPB Complaint #260703-35019175 (Willful Escalation & Fraudulent Notice to Cure) (2 pages)
- Exhibit Q: CFPB Complaint #260715-35566906 (Congressional Casework Inquiry & Repossession) (2 pages)
|
JOSEPH R. FEARS Plaintiff v. USAA FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK Defendant |
Case No.: ____________________ |
I, Joseph R. Fears, wish to file a Verified Complaint and Emergency Motion for Temporary Restraining Order in this matter. I am unable to prepay the required court filing costs because of poverty and severe financial hardship.
Affidavit of Income
- Household Size: Father of three children with a pregnant wife (5 dependents).
- Employment Status: Affected by a recent Reduction in Force (RIF), resulting in severe loss of primary income.
- Gross Monthly Household Income: Significantly below federal poverty thresholds following involuntary termination/RIF.
- Assets:
- Real Estate: $0.00
- Bank Account Balance: Minimal operational liquidity
- Personal Property / Vehicles: 2025 Chevrolet Traverse (VIN: IGNEVGRSISJ123332), wrongfully seized by Defendant on July 24, 2026.
- Debts & Liabilities: Substantial outstanding living and medical expenses following RIF. Furthermore, Plaintiff is currently assigned a Taxpayer Advocate Service (TAS) caseworker due to severe delays in tax returns, compounding the liquidity crisis.
- Additional Hardship Information: On July 24, 2026, Defendant USAA executed an unauthorized physical repossession of Plaintiff's primary vehicle, depriving Plaintiff of essential personal transportation necessary to secure replacement full-time employment and conduct basic life activities.
I solemnly affirm under the penalties of perjury that the contents of this document are true to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief.
|
JOSEPH R. FEARS Plaintiff v. USAA FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK Defendant |
Case No.: ____________________ |
Plaintiff Joseph R. Fears, appearing Pro Se, files this Verified Complaint against Defendant USAA Federal Savings Bank ("USAA"), alleging as follows:
I. JURISDICTION AND VENUE
1. Venue is proper in Harford County, Maryland, pursuant to Md. Code Ann., Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 6-201, as the unlawful physical conversion and repossession of the subject vehicle occurred within Harford County under Harford County Sheriff Incident Report #202600168263.
2. This Court has equitable jurisdiction to issue injunctive relief pursuant to Maryland Rule 15-501 et seq.
II. PARTIES AND SUBJECT ASSET
3. Plaintiff Joseph R. Fears is an individual residing in Maryland.
4. Defendant USAA Federal Savings Bank is a federally chartered savings bank doing business in Maryland.
5. The subject asset is a 2025 Chevrolet Traverse, VIN: IGNEVGRSISJ123332 (the "Vehicle").
III. STATEMENT OF FACTS AND UNASSAILABLE ADMINISTRATIVE TIMELINE
6. On April 17, 2026, Plaintiff initiated formal dispute communications with Defendant regarding defect notices and claims under the FTC Holder Rule (16 C.F.R. § 433). On May 13, 2026, Defendant's Executive Resolution / Legal Department formally accepted service of Plaintiff's FTC Holder Rule notice via USPS Certified Mail (Tracking #9590 9402 9892 5335 7297 12), removing any plausible deniability of the dispute.
7. On July 22, 2026, a formal Congressional Inquiry was opened on Plaintiff’s behalf through U.S. Senator Angela Alsobrooks and logged directly into the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB Case #260715-35566906). Under CFPB statutory guidelines, Defendant USAA is mandated to provide a formal, on-the-record response or file a formal extension no later than August 6, 2026.
8. On July 23, 2026, the Office of the Attorney General of Texas (Consumer Protection Division, Complaint #TCP-046639) issued formal notice establishing that Defendant USAA failed and refused to respond to state regulatory inquiries regarding Plaintiff's FTC Holder Rule disputes.
9. On July 24, 2026, Assistant Attorney General Lauren Downey formally certified (R033452-072026) that zero responsive records existed from USAA.
10. On July 24, 2026, a mere 48 hours after the Senatorial and CFPB inquiries were logged, and 24 hours after ignoring the Texas Attorney General, Defendant USAA dispatched recovery agents to execute an unauthorized physical repossession of the Vehicle in Harford County (Incident Report #202600168263).
11. On July 27, 2026, Plaintiff issued a formal Notice of Administrative Error and Demand for Record Retraction directly to USAA's Executive Management and Office of the General Counsel.
12. Defendant has noticed an unconscionable public/private liquidation auction of the Vehicle scheduled on or about August 8, 2026.
IV. CAUSES OF ACTION
COUNT I: WRONGFUL CONVERSION AND RETALIATION
13. Plaintiff incorporates paragraphs 1 through 12 by reference.
14. Defendant took unauthorized physical possession of Plaintiff's Vehicle without legal authority while active administrative and regulatory holds were pending under CFPB Case #260715-35566906.
15. Said seizure was executed in bad faith and in direct retaliation for Plaintiff exercising protected rights under federal and state consumer protection statutes.
COUNT II: VIOLATIONS OF UCC ARTICLE 9 (BREACH OF PEACE & IMPROPER DISPOSITION)
16. Defendant violated Maryland Commercial Law Code Ann. § 9-601 et seq. by dispatching recovery orders during an unresolved statutory dispute under 16 C.F.R. § 433 and failing to provide proper, valid statutory notices prior to attempted liquidation.
COUNT III: SPOLIATION OF ELECTRONICALLY STORED INFORMATION (ESI)
17. Defendant was served with formal ESI preservation directives concerning telematics data and Diagnostic Trouble Codes (including ECU DTC U1962). Proceeding to auction will destroy vital physical and electronic evidence.
COUNT IV: ONGOING VIOLATION OF ACTIVE FEDERAL CONSENT ORDER & UDAAP
18. Plaintiff explicitly alleges that Defendant's actions in this matter constitute a direct, ongoing violation of the comprehensive Cease-and-Desist Order issued against USAA Federal Savings Bank by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) on December 18, 2024. The OCC explicitly cited USAA for engaging in unsafe and unsound practices, including catastrophic, systemic failures in their Compliance Management System (CMS). Defendant's documented failure to execute mandatory administrative investigations, the weaponization of the CFPB portal to bury disputes, and the retaliatory issuance of fraudulent statutory notices are direct manifestations of the exact systemic CMS failures the OCC has ordered USAA to rectify.
V. PRAYER FOR RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests that this Court:
A. Issue an Emergency Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction enjoining Defendant, its agents, and vendors from selling, auctioning, transferring, or liquidating the 2025 Chevrolet Traverse (VIN: IGNEVGRSISJ123332).
B. Order Defendant to immediately return physical possession of the Vehicle to Plaintiff.
C. Order Defendant to issue e-OSCAR trade line deletions and correct law enforcement records with the Harford County Sheriff's Office.
D. Award statutory, compensatory, and punitive damages for willful and reckless non-compliance.
E. Plaintiff expressly reserves the right to amend this Verified Complaint and submit supplemental, newly discovered evidence and/or exhibits into the official record as expedited discovery proceeds.
VERIFICATION
I solemnly affirm under the penalties of perjury that the contents of this Verified Complaint are true to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief.
|
JOSEPH R. FEARS Plaintiff v. USAA FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK Defendant |
Case No.: ____________________ |
Plaintiff Joseph R. Fears moves this Court pursuant to Maryland Rule 15-504 for an Emergency Ex Parte Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction, stating:
1. Immediate Irreparable Harm: Defendant USAA has scheduled a liquidation auction of Plaintiff's primary vehicle (2025 Chevrolet Traverse, VIN: IGNEVGRSISJ123332) on or about August 8, 2026. Once sold to a third party, this unique chattel and the underlying onboard ESI/telematics evidence will be permanently lost, creating immediate and irreparable injury.
2. Likelihood of Success on the Merits: Government records prove Defendant seized the vehicle a mere 48 hours after a U.S. Senate/CFPB inquiry was opened, and exactly 13 days prior to their mandatory August 6, 2026 CFPB response deadline. Defendant executed this seizure precisely to liquidate the evidence and moot the federal dispute before they were forced to answer to regulators. Furthermore, as proven by Exhibits J and L, Defendant exhibits a documented pattern of evading state regulatory oversight, having willfully ignored formal investigative inquiries from the Texas Attorney General. Most damningly, Plaintiff alleges Defendant's actions are in direct, ongoing violation of the active, comprehensive Cease-and-Desist Order issued against USAA by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) on December 18, 2024, which explicitly cited USAA for catastrophic, systemic failures in their Compliance Management System (CMS). Defendant's actions perfectly mirror the "unsafe and unsound practices" for which they are actively under federal penalty.
3. Balance of Convenience: Enjoining the auction maintains the status quo. Defendant suffers zero prejudice by holding an asset for full hearing, whereas Plaintiff loses essential transportation and irreplaceable evidence.
4. Public Interest: The public interest is served by compelling financial institutions to comply with statutory administrative holds and state regulatory inquiries before seizing consumer property.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays that this Court immediately enter an Ex Parte Temporary Restraining Order enjoining Defendant from auctioning, transferring, or altering the subject vehicle.
|
JOSEPH R. FEARS Plaintiff v. USAA FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK Defendant |
Case No.: ____________________ |
Plaintiff Joseph R. Fears respectfully moves this Court to waive the requirement of an injunction bond pursuant to Maryland Rule 15-503(c), stating:
1. Maryland Rule 15-503(c) explicitly grants this Court authority to waive a bond in cases of extraordinary hardship where requiring a bond would result in substantial injustice.
2. Plaintiff recently suffered an involuntary Reduction in Force (RIF), resulting in severe loss of household income and employment.
3. Requiring Plaintiff to post a financial bond to protect his wrongfully seized primary vehicle from an unauthorized August 8, 2026 auction would completely bar Plaintiff from access to judicial relief, perpetuating a severe injustice.
4. Defendant USAA is a multi-billion-dollar financial institution and holds full physical possession of the collateral, guaranteeing zero financial risk during the brief pendency of a Temporary Restraining Order.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests that this Court issue an order completely waiving the injunction bond requirement under Rule 15-503(c).
|
JOSEPH R. FEARS Plaintiff v. USAA FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK Defendant |
Case No.: ____________________ |
State of Maryland, County of Harford, to wit:
I, Joseph R. Fears, being over 18 years of age and competent to testify, solemnly affirm under penalties of perjury:
1. I am the Plaintiff in the above-captioned matter and the registered owner of the 2025 Chevrolet Traverse (VIN: IGNEVGRSISJ123332).
2. I am a father of three children with a pregnant wife. I recently experienced an involuntary Reduction in Force (RIF) from my employment. This loss of income, combined with severe tax return delays currently being managed by my assigned Taxpayer Advocate Service (TAS) caseworker, has drastically reduced my financial resources, making it impossible to prepay court costs or post a monetary injunction bond.
3. On July 22, 2026, U.S. Senator Angela Alsobrooks’ office initiated an official inquiry regarding my financial disputes, logged under CFPB Case #260715-35566906, establishing a mandatory response deadline for USAA of August 6, 2026.
4. On July 23, 2026, the Texas Attorney General confirmed Defendant USAA failed and refused to respond to state regulatory inquiries regarding my file (Complaint #TCP-046639), as documented in Exhibits J and L.
5. On July 24, 2026, USAA dispatched recovery agents to physically seize my vehicle in Harford County (Sheriff Incident Report #202600168263).
6. USAA has noticed the vehicle for public/private auction on or about August 8, 2026. Without emergency injunctive relief, I will suffer permanent loss of my family's sole vehicle, depriving my pregnant wife and children of essential transportation for medical care, as well as the loss of critical ESI evidence.
I solemnly affirm under the penalties of perjury that the contents of this Affidavit are true to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief.
|
JOSEPH R. FEARS Plaintiff v. USAA FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK Defendant |
Case No.: ____________________ |
Upon consideration of Plaintiff’s Request for Waiver of Prepaid Costs (Md. Rule 1-325), it is this ____ day of __________________, 2026, by the Circuit Court for Harford County, hereby:
ORDERED, that Plaintiff's Request for Waiver of Prepaid Costs is GRANTED, and all prepaid filing fees are hereby WAIVED.
Upon consideration of Plaintiff’s Motion to Waive Injunction Bond, it is this ____ day of __________________, 2026, hereby:
ORDERED, that pursuant to Maryland Rule 15-503(c), the requirement of posting an injunction bond is WAIVED in full due to extraordinary hardship and substantial injustice.
|
JOSEPH R. FEARS Plaintiff v. USAA FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK Defendant |
Case No.: ____________________ |
Upon consideration of Plaintiff’s Emergency Motion for Ex Parte Temporary Restraining Order, Verified Complaint, and supporting Affidavit, the Court finds that immediate, substantial, and irreparable harm will result to Plaintiff before a full hearing can be held, specifically the permanent loss of unique personal property (2025 Chevrolet Traverse, VIN: IGNEVGRSISJ123332) at auction on August 8, 2026.
It is this ____ day of __________________, 2026, at _____:_____ AM/PM, hereby:
ORDERED, that Defendant USAA Federal Savings Bank, its agents, contractors, repossession vendors, and auction facilities are ENJOINED and RESTRAINED from selling, liquidating, transferring, conveying, moving, or altering the 2025 Chevrolet Traverse (VIN: IGNEVGRSISJ123332); and it is further
ORDERED, that this Order shall remain in effect until the ____ day of __________________, 2026, or until further order of this Court.
|
JOSEPH R. FEARS Plaintiff v. USAA FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK Defendant |
Case No.: ____________________ |
Plaintiff Joseph R. Fears respectfully moves this Court for an order granting expedited discovery and compelling Defendant USAA Federal Savings Bank to immediately preserve and produce critical Electronically Stored Information (ESI), stating:
1. Imminent Risk of Spoliation: Defendant operates massive, automated data-retention systems. Routine document destruction protocols threaten to permanently delete critical evidence—specifically internal compliance script trays, employee workflow manuals, and customer service call recordings from April 17, 2026, wherein Defendant's agents repeatedly disconnected Plaintiff when attempting to invoke federal statutory rights.
2. Legal Duty to Preserve: Under Maryland and highly persuasive federal precedent established in this jurisdiction, the duty to preserve ESI is triggered the moment litigation is reasonably anticipated. See Victor Stanley, Inc. v. Creative Pipe, Inc., 269 F.R.D. 497 (D. Md. 2010) (Grimm, J.) (establishing stringent standards for ESI litigation holds and sanctions for spoliation); see also Klupt v. Krongard, 126 Md. App. 179 (1999) (affirming severe sanctions, including dismissal or default judgment, for the destruction of discoverable evidence). The Congressional and State Attorney General inquiries logged on July 22 and July 23, 2026, unequivocally triggered Defendant's duty to implement a litigation hold.
3. Expedited Discovery Required: Standard discovery timelines are insufficient. Plaintiff requires expedited production of the exact internal workflow manuals and "script trays" Defendant's agents relied upon to ignore federal defect notices and unlawfully deploy recovery agents 48 hours after a U.S. Senate inquiry was logged.
4. Telematics and ECU Data: Plaintiff further demands the immediate preservation of all onboard vehicle telematics and Diagnostic Trouble Code (DTC) logs transmitted to Defendant regarding the 2025 Chevrolet Traverse, which establish the underlying mechanical failure (DTC U1962) and justify Plaintiff's revocation of acceptance.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays that this Court enter an Order directing Defendant to immediately suspend routine electronic deletion protocols and grant Plaintiff expedited discovery to obtain the aforementioned ESI.
- This formal complaint establishes the administrative record of USAA’s systemic UDAAP violations and FTC Holder Rule evasion.
- It implies USAA was fully aware of the legal dispute at the state level prior to executing an extrajudicial repossession.
- This official notice from the Texas Attorney General confirms USAA failed and refused to voluntarily respond to state regulatory inquiries.
- It implies USAA intentionally bypassed regulatory oversight, operating in bad faith to enforce a voidable contract rather than defend their actions.
- This follow-up notice further documents the State's inability to resolve the matter due to USAA's willful non-compliance and absolute silence.
- It proves USAA’s pattern of administrative evasion, forcing Plaintiff to seek emergency injunctive relief to stop the liquidation of evidence.
- An explicit written certification from Assistant Attorney General Lauren Downey confirming absolutely zero response was ever provided by USAA.
- It definitively establishes USAA’s refusal to cooperate with law enforcement, proving their physical seizure of the asset was a retaliatory tactic to moot the state's jurisdiction.
- This manufacturer diagnostic report confirms severe, systemic transmission defects (U1962) and critical telemetry/safety failures (U0452).
- It definitively establishes that the vehicle sold to Plaintiff is substantially impaired, unmerchantable, and unsafe to operate, triggering the absolute right to unwind the contract under the FTC Holder Rule.
- This official communication from the manufacturer acknowledges a systemic manufacturing defect (coolant/radiator hose leak) present in the 2025 Chevrolet Traverse.
- Coupled with Exhibit M, it proves beyond any reasonable doubt that the collateral securing USAA's loan is defective, affirming USAA's derivative liability for the seller's breach of warranty under 16 CFR § 433.
- This initial CFPB complaint documents Plaintiff's explicit, timely invocation of the FTC Holder in Due Course Rule to USAA for a statutory 34-day Breach of Warranty.
- It proves USAA was formally placed on federal notice that the underlying sales contract was voidable, yet USAA maliciously instructed the Plaintiff to "work directly with your dealership" in bad faith to evade 16 C.F.R. § 433 liability.
- This CFPB escalation exposes USAA's retaliatory issuance of a legally deficient "Notice of Right to Cure" containing impossible, back-dated deadlines designed to illegally bypass the Plaintiff's statutory rights.
- It establishes a clear timeline of retaliatory UDAAP and FDCPA violations executed by USAA immediately following their tacit admission of prior credit reporting violations.
- This complaint documents the active Congressional Casework intervention initiated by U.S. Senator Angela Alsobrooks due to USAA's systemic compliance failures and dispute evasion.
- Because USAA executed the physical seizure of the vehicle exactly 48 hours after this inquiry was opened, it strongly implies the repossession was an illegal, retaliatory spoliation tactic designed to liquidate the asset before the mandated August 6th CFPB response deadline.
Index of Filed Exhibits (A through Q)
All exhibits were formally submitted with the 33-page Emergency Ex Parte TRO filing in Harford County Circuit Court.